Skip to main content

Table 2 Characteristics of included subjects

From: Effectiveness and safety of Tuina massage therapy for paediatric fever: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials

First author, year

Population

Age

Body temperature

Duration of fever

Room temperature

Measurement site

Measurement device

Time of follow-up

Agbolosu, 1997 [12]

Children consistent with upper respiratory tract infections and/or malaria

6–60 months

38.5–40℃

1–14 days

21–32℃

Axillary

Digital thermometer

60/120 min

Aksoylar, 1997 [13]

Children with fever of ≥ 39℃ due to different etiology

6 months-5 years

 ≥ 39℃

NR

NR

Rectal

Mercury thermometer

30/60/120/180 min

Alves, 2008 [14]

Children consistent with upper respiratory tract infections

24.9 ± 8.3 months; 21.9 ± 7.1 months

38.5–40℃

Mean: 24.5 and 22.6 h

27–30℃

Axillary

Digital thermometer

0/15/30/60/90/120 min

Deng, 2023 [15]

Children consistent with upper respiratory tract infections

1–7 years

 ≥ 37.5℃

4.37 ± 0.56 days; 4.62 ± 0.62 days

NR

NR

Thermometer

Within 5 days

Gong, 2018 [16]

Children consistent with upper respiratory tract infections

6 months-6 years

37.5–39.0℃

12 h-9 days

NR

NR

Thermometer

0/6/12/24/36 h

Huang, 2021 [17]

Children consistent with upper respiratory tract infections

6 months-6 years

37.5–40.0℃

3–23 days

NR

NR

Thermometer

0/6/12/24/36 h

Hunter, 1973 [18]

Children with fever of ≥ 39.5℃ rectally presenting to the hospital

6 months-5 years

 ≥ 39.5℃

NR

NR

Oral

NR

240 min

Kinmonth, 1992 [19]

Homes of willing families with a feverish child recruited after consulting one of 2 l participating general practitioners in Southampton

3 months-5 years

37.8–39.9℃

NR

NR

Axillary

Digital thermometer

240 min

Li, 2018 [20]

Fever children who presented to the hospital

1–8 years

NR

NR

NR

NR

Thermometer

30/60/120/180 min

Mahar, 1994 [21]

Children consistent with viral infection

6 months-5 years

 ≥ 38.5℃

NR

29.4℃

Rectal

Electronic thermometer

120 min

Newman, 1985 [22]

Fever children admitted to the emergency department

0.25–2 years

 ≥ 39.0℃

NR

NR

Rectal

Mercury thermometer

50 min

Sharber, 1997 [23]

All subjects presented to the emergency department with a complaint of fever

5 −68 months

 ≥ 38.9℃

NR

23.9–27.2℃

Rectal

Infrared tympanic thermometer

120 min

Steele, 1970 [24]

Fever children who presented at the Pediatric Clinic with febrile illnesses

6 months-5 years

 ≥ 39.4℃

 ≤ 3 days

25.5℃

Rectal

Mercury thermometer

120 min

Thomas, 2009 [25]

Fever children who presented to the hospital

6 months-12 years

 ≥ 38.3℃

NR

−0.5℃

Axillary

Thermometer

0/15/30/45/60/90/120 min

Wu, 2019 [26]

Fever children who presented to the hospital

1–8 years

NR

NR

NR

NR

Thermometer

NR

  1. NR not reported