Skip to main content

Table 2 Characteristics of the Included Studies

From: Do physical fitness and motor skill performances in underweight children differ from normal weight peers? A meta-analysis

Study/Reference

Study design

Study duration

Country

Rural versus urban

Number of children

Age range (years)

The instrument/battery for assessing physical fitness/motor skill

PF/MS

Total

Boys

Armstrong 2016

CS

2001–2004

South African children

Both

10 285

5 604

6–13

EUROFIT: standing long jump, shuttle run, sit and reach, sit-ups and cricket ball throw

PF

Arsenault 2011

CS

2006

Bogota, Colombia

Urban

1945

916

5–12

EUROFIT: shuttle run, standing long jump

PF

Battaglia 2021

CS

2019- 2020

Italy

Urban

1 961

1 026

6–13

KTK: jumping laterally, shifting platforms, hopping on one leg

MS

Bénéfice, 1998

CS

/

Senegal

Rural

140

66

8.5–13.5

50-m dash, standing long jump, throw, grip strength, step-test

PF

Chen 2022

L

/

Xinjiang China

urban and rural

17 356

8671

7–18

Chinese National Survey Students Constitution and Health guidelines: grip strength, standing long jump, sit and reach, 50-m dash, endurance run

PF

Chowdhury 2010

CS

/

Santal, India

Rural

841

427

5–12

BOT-2-SF: full push-ups, sit-ups

PF

BOT-2-SF: drawing lines through crooked path, folding paper, copying a square, copying a star, transferring pennies, jumping in place, tapping feet and finger, walking forward on a line, standing on one leg, one-legged stationary hop, dropping and catching ball, dribbling a ball,

MS

Goldstein 2020

CS

/

Israel

Urban

286

144

7–9 years

Standing long-jump, vertical jump test, bent arm hang test, modified pull-up test

PF

KTK

MS

Gontarev 2018

CS

2013

Macedonia

Both

9 081

4 608

6–14 years

EUROFIT: sit-ups, bent arm hang, handgrip test, sit and reach, 4 × 10 shuttle run, standing broad jump

PF

Kryst 2016

L

2007–2011

Poland: Kraków and Tarnów

Urban

469

252

4–6 years

EUROFIT: sit and reach, standing broad jump, handgrip test

PF

Lopes 2018

CS

/

Azores islands, Portugal

Urban

3 738

1 912

6–10

KTK

MS

Malina 2011

CS

/

Mexico

Both

152

73

6–12

Sit and reach, sit-ups, distance run, hand grip strength, standing long jump, 50-m dash

PF

Monyeki 2005

CS

2000

South Africa

Rural

855

462

7–14

EUROFIT: bent arm hang, standing long jump, sit-ups, sit and reach, 10 × 5 m shuttle run, plate tapping and flamingo balance

PF

Roberts 2012

CS

2001–2008

all across the United States

Both

4 650

2 150

4.6–6.2

BOT-MP: standing long jump, balance on one foot, skipping 8 steps

PF

MABC: Catching beanbag, walking backwards

MS

Santos 2020

L

2009- 2010

Peru, South America

Both

483

246

6–12 year

EUROFIT: grip strength, standing long jump, shuttle-run

AAHPERD: 12 min run

PF

Serrano-Gallén 2022

CS

2019

Cuenca, Spain

urban

150

70

3–6 years

PREFIT: grip strength, standing long jump, sit and reach, 4 × 10 m shuttle run, 20-m shuttle run

PF

Šekeljić 2019

CS

/

Serbia

Urban

180

180

10

Standing long jump, throwing a medicine ball, lifting the trunk, stretching the trunk, Hanging pull-ups (sec), grip strength, 20-m run, 30-m run, hand plate tapping, leg plate tapping, deep bent(cm), spagat(cm)

PF

Standing on one leg across the balance bench, standing on one leg with eyes closed, twenty steps with moving through the sticks, bouncing of a ball, shooting a horizontal target, darts

MS

Shang 2010

CS

/

Eastern China

Urban

226

70

6–12

Standing long jump, 50-m dash, 8 × 50 m shuttle run

PF

Smith 2020

CS

2015

South Africa

Both

965

498

8–12

EUROFIT: 20-m shuttle run test, grip strength, standing long jump

PF

Verbecque 2022

CS

2019

Ghana and South Africa

Both

853

459

5.8–12.9

PERF-FIT: running, stepping, side jump, standing long jump (peak power), overhead throw

PF

Yip 2022

CS

2017–2018

Hong Kong, China

Urban

5 909

2 688

6–17

EUROFIT: grip strength, Push-ups, mini-sit-ups, sit and reach, 6 min run/walk, 9 min run/walk

PF

Yip 2024

CS

2018- 2019

Hong Kong China

Urban

90 684

46 707

6–12

EUROFIT: grip strength, sit-ups, sit and reach, endurance run

PF

Zhang 2019

CS

2015

China

Both

5 254

2 526

8.6–12.5

15-m PACER, standing long jump, 50-m sprint

PF

  1. Abbreviations: CS: cross-sectional; L: longitudinal; PF: Physical fitness; MS: motor skills; KTK: Körperkoordinationstest für Kinder; BOT-2-SF: Bruininks–Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency-Second Edition, short form; MABC: Movement Assessment Battery for Children; PERF-FIT: Performance and fitness battery; AAHPERD: The American Alliance for Health, Physical Education and Recreation Distance run; EUROFIT: European Fitness test battery